Direct Energy vs Cirro Energy.Which one actually costs you less?
Two no-gimmick flat-rate providers compared. We priced both plans against YOUR real kWh — the honest number, not the advertised teaser rate.
Voltcheckr LLC is a registered Texas electricity broker (PUCT Broker Registration BR260102), not a retail electric provider, and has no affiliated provider. We are paid a referral commission by the supplier you choose — never by you. You can stop using Voltcheckr at any time at no cost. By continuing you acknowledge our broker disclosures.
No bill? Estimate your savings instantly.
Moving, between bills, or prefer not to upload.
No file · No email · No catch.
Who wins?
These two are the closest head-to-head in Texas electricity. Both sell simple fixed-rate plans without bill credits, and both typically price within 0.3-0.5¢/kWh of each other. Direct Energy has a larger plan catalog and slightly better customer service reviews. Cirro has marginally lower base charges which gives them an edge at low usage (under 800 kWh). At 1,000+ kWh the difference is genuinely negligible — pick whichever has the better rate the week you're shopping. The real takeaway: both are almost always cheaper than the big brands (TXU, Reliant) because they don't spend on TV advertising.
- •Fixed-rate
- •Renewable blend
- Predictable billing
- Set-and-forget customers
- •Fixed-rate
- •Simple tiered pricing
- Variable usage households
- Transparent-pricing buyers
Stop guessing. See who wins at YOUR usage.
Upload your bill (or type your kWh) and we'll calculate which provider actually saves you more against your exact numbers — not an average that matches nobody.
Price both for my usage →Still researching?Grab the free guide.
We'll email you the free plain-English guide to Texas electricity shopping, how bill credit traps work, which plan types to avoid, and the 3 questions to ask before you sign. 5-minute read.
- How to read your current bill (and spot hidden fees)
- Why the advertised rate is almost never what you actually pay
- The exact questions to ask before you sign a 12-month plan
- When to lock in vs go month-to-month